Blocked due to other 4xx issue
What it means
‘Blocked due to other 4xx issue’ is a status shown in Google Search Console‘s Page indexing report. The official help defines it as “The server encountered a 4xx error not covered by any other issue type described here.” GSC Help Center All 400-range errors other than codes that have their own label, such as 401 (authentication required), 403 (forbidden) and 404 (not found), are grouped under this status. The Korean-language help lists it under the submitted-URL label “Submitted URL blocked due to other 4xx issue,” but it is the same status as the ‘Blocked due to other 4xx issue’ shown on the Search Console screen. It is also often called an ‘other 4xx error.’
A 4xx is a 400-range response in which the server says “there is a problem on the requesting side.” Think of it as a post office’s set of return-to-sender stamps. ‘Addressee unknown (404),’ ‘ID check required (401)’ and ‘Delivery refused (403)’ each have their own slot, and returned mail that fits none of them ends up in the ‘Other’ slot. This status is that ‘Other’ slot.
Is it a problem or not?
URLs in this status are not getting into the index. Whether that is a problem depends on one question: “Should this page appear in search results?”
- If the page should appear in search, it is a problem. Googlebot is not receiving its content, so you need to find the cause and fix it.
- If you removed the page on purpose, it is normal behavior. A deleted page dropping out of the index is the intended result, so no action is needed.
What happens if you leave it: the common 4xx rule
Google’s official crawling documentation states that “all 4xx errors, except 429, are treated the same,” and the crawler passes them on to the next processing systems as a signal that the content does not exist. Google (official) There are three results.
- Excluded from the index: URLs that return a 4xx are not newly indexed, and “URLs that are already indexed and now return a 4xx status code are removed from the index.”
- Content ignored: “Any content Google received from URLs that return a 4xx status code is ignored.”
- Less crawling: the URL’s “crawling frequency gradually decreases.”
Which codes end up here: 400, 410, 411 and 429
The same Google crawling document covers these 4xx codes: 400, 401, 403, 404, 410, 411 and 429. Of these, 401, 403 and 404 have their own statuses, so the candidates for ‘other 4xx’ are mainly the following.
- 400 (Bad Request): the server could not understand the request itself. This happens when URL parameters are broken or the server configuration misreads the request.
- 410 (Gone): a code used to tell crawlers that a deleted page was “removed on purpose.”
- 411 (Length Required): the server rejected the request because it had no size information. This is usually a server configuration issue.
- 429 (Too Many Requests): a rate-limit response telling the client it is requesting too often and to slow down. It happens when a WAF (web application firewall) or bot protection returns this code to Googlebot. However, Google treats 429 like a server error, so the report may list it under server errors (5xx) instead.
In practice, the most common cause is bot protection or rate-limit settings. People can view the page just fine, but the firewall returns a 400-range response only to Googlebot’s requests. It is like a security guard mistaking the delivery driver for a thief and turning them away.
Start by checking the actual response code
Google’s official recommended action for this status is just one: “Use the URL Inspection tool to debug the page.” Step 1 is the live test in the URL Inspection tool. The first inspection screen shows past records, “results for the most recently indexed version,” so you need to run the live test to see, as success or failure, whether Google can fetch the page right now. GSC Help Center
Step 2 is reproducing the response code. Open the problem URL in a browser and, if possible, check the status code with a command like the one below. If you are not a developer, ask your developer or hosting provider.
curl -I https://www.example.com/page/
HTTP/1.1 400 Bad Request
Step 3 is the server logs and firewall logs. Sometimes a page returns normal (200) in a browser but a 4xx only to Googlebot, so check both separately. If you suspect a 429, look at your bot protection logs first.
What to do for each code
If the page should be live, the fix is to find the cause code on the server or firewall and restore a normal response (200). Google states clearly here, “Don’t use 401 and 403 status codes for limiting the crawl rate.” Google (official) 4xx codes other than 429 have no effect on crawl rate, so using a 4xx to reduce load does not reduce load; it only drops pages from the index. In February 2023, the Google Search Central Blog also published a separate post urging sites and CDNs (content delivery networks) not to do this, as more of them were using 4xx codes (other than 429) to slow down Googlebot’s crawling. Google official blog
If you urgently need to lower the crawl rate, the official route is to return 500, 503 or 429 for a short period (from 2–3 hours to 1–2 days), not a regular 4xx. However, Google warns, “If Googlebot finds these status codes on the same URL for multiple days, the URL may be dropped from Google’s index.” Google (official) It is a stopgap for a few days, not a permanent setting.
If 429 is the cause, there is one more thing to check. 429 is a 400-range code, but the same crawling document explains, “Google’s crawlers treat the 429 status code as a signal that the server is overloaded, and it’s considered a server error.” Ahrefs also notes that 429 is treated like a server error, so Google slows its crawling, and if it continues, the page eventually drops out of the index too. Ahrefs The official documentation does not say which Search Console status 429 is classified under, so it is safer to check the actual response code rather than trust the label alone.
If a page you removed on purpose shows up in this status, there is nothing to fix, and you don’t need to agonize over 404 versus 410. In 2024, John Mueller answered that the difference in how 404 and 410 are handled is so tiny that there is no reason to prefer either one for SEO, and that Google does not penalize 404s. John Mueller’s remarks
How it differs from codes with their own status
‘Other 4xx’ is the slot for everything that does not fit the statuses below. If a URL shows up in one of these statuses, follow the fix for that entry.
- Blocked due to unauthorized request (401): Googlebot is blocked by a page that requires login or authentication. It has its own status.
- Blocked due to access forbidden (403): the server refused access outright. This also has its own status.
- Not found (404): the most common response saying the page does not exist, classified as a separate status.
- Server error (5xx): a 500-range response meaning the fault is on the server side. Unlike the 400 range, the page stays indexed for a while and is removed only if the error persists.
- Blocked by robots.txt: not a response code problem, but access blocked by the crawl rules file. It is like a sign at the door barring entry, so the fix is completely different.
References
- Page indexing report – Google Search Console Help
- How HTTP status codes affect Google’s crawlers – Google Search Central
- Reduce the Google crawl rate – Google Search Central
- Don’t use 403s or 404s for rate limiting – Google Search Central Blog (2023)
- URL Inspection tool – Google Search Console Help
- Report on John Mueller’s 404 vs. 410 remarks – Search Engine Journal (2024)
- HTTP status codes and their SEO impact – Ahrefs
Jul.2026By Studio JT