Not found (404)
What It Means
“Not found (404)” is the status where Googlebot requested a specific URL and the server returned an HTTP 404 response, in other words “no such page,” so Google did not add the page to its index or removed it from the existing index. In Google Search Console’s Page indexing report, it appears as one of the reasons under “Not indexed,” and the official documentation describes it as “This page returned a 404 error when requested.” GSC Help Center
404 is not a concept invented by a particular search engine; it is a standard web response code. MDN defines 404 as “a response status code that indicates that the server cannot find the requested resource.” MDN (standard) This Search Console report doesn’t create new errors; it simply gathers and shows the 404 responses your server was already sending.
Does It Hurt Rankings?
The short answer: most 404s are not a problem. Google Search Central says “404 errors are a perfectly normal part of the web,” and that as new content appears and old content disappears, returning a 404 is the preferred approach. Google (official) On rankings, it also states explicitly that the fact some URLs return 404 “does not impact how other URLs that return 200 (successful) perform in search results.” Google (official)
The data backs up this principle. When Ahrefs analyzed backlinks to about 2.06 million sites, at least 66.5% of links created since 2013 had already died (link rot). Ahrefs data Pages disappearing and leaving a 404 behind is not the exception; it is how the web normally works.
So Google’s official position boils down to two points. First, a 404 by itself doesn’t lower rankings. Second, a deleted page returning a 404 is normal and actually the recommended behavior. Google says that when you remove a page, it prefers you honestly return a 404 or 410 rather than a “soft 404” that sends visitors to the home page. Google (official)
Why 404s Show Up: Common Causes
- Pages you deleted on purpose – old events, sold-out products, removed posts. This is normal and fine to leave as is.
- Old or mistyped URLs left in internal links or sitemaps – Google follows those links and requests addresses that don’t exist.
- Broken links from external sites – when another site links to a mistyped address, Google tries that address.
- Important pages that vanished by mistake – deployment accidents, slug changes, CMS errors. Only these actually need fixing.
When to Act
Google’s documentation distinguishes between “deleted” and “moved.” The Page indexing report says, “If the page was removed without a replacement, a 404 response isn’t necessarily a problem,” and if the content has moved, it recommends you “use a 301 redirect to the new location.” GSC Help Center The test is simple: is it okay for this URL to disappear?
| Situation | Action | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Page removed on purpose, no replacement | Keep the 404 (no action needed) | 404 is a normal response |
| Content moved to a different URL | 301 redirect to the new location | Google: “use a 301 redirect to the new location” |
| An important URL with backlinks or traffic disappeared | Restore the page or 301 to the most relevant page | Preserves link value and user experience |
| You want to signal permanent removal clearly | Consider returning 410 (Gone) | See “404 vs 410” below |
The key point is don’t cover every 404 with a redirect. If you send hundreds of missing pages to the home page no matter what, Google may classify them as soft 404s. Mass redirects to unrelated pages don’t solve the problem; they create a new one.
404 vs 410: How Fast Pages Leave the Index
Site owners often confuse these. A 404 means “can’t find it right now,” while a 410 (Gone) means “permanently gone.” Yet the “same treatment” described in the official documentation and the “difference in crawl frequency” seen in experiments don’t quite line up. The table below sums up why, and how to decide in practice.
| Google’s official position | The indexing pipeline treats all 4xx errors except 429 the same way: whether 404 or 410, previously indexed URLs are removed from the index. The end result is the same. Google (official) |
|---|---|
| Expert measurements | Reboot Online tracked 119 pages for more than three months and found Google recrawled 404 URLs 49.6% more often than 410 URLs (95% confidence level). This suggests Google trusts a 410 as “permanently removed” sooner. Reboot data |
The difference comes from Google’s habit of double-checking. Even after getting a 404, Google tends to come back to confirm the page is “really gone,” whereas it takes a 410 as a permanent removal signal right away. Google’s John Mueller has also explained that a 410 tends to drop out of the index a little faster than a 404, but usually only by a few days. SEJ report The practical conclusion is simple: if a page already returns a 404, Google will remove it from the index on its own, so there is little benefit in switching to 410. It’s enough to pin down with a 410 only the pages that “must never be indexed again,” such as spam URLs created by a hack.
Tips for Checking and Fixing
- Click the example URLs in the report and first check whether it’s actually fine for those addresses to be gone. Most can simply be left alone.
- If an important page shows up as a 404, restore it or 301 it to a relevant page, then recheck its status with the URL Inspection tool.
- Check that no dead URLs remain in your sitemap or internal links. It’s best not to include 404 URLs in your sitemap.
- If the number of 404s suddenly spikes, it may signal a deployment accident or mass deletion, so look into the cause.
- Prepare a custom 404 page that gently guides users who hit a broken link to the home page or search, and you can reduce drop-offs. You can see well-made examples in STUDIO-JT’s collection of 404 error page designs.
For related concepts, see soft 404, which looks like a 404 but returns 200 so Google classifies it separately; 301 redirect, the right way to handle moved pages; and the Page indexing report, where this status appears.
References
- Page indexing report – Google Search Console Help
- Do 404 errors hurt my site? – Google Search Central Blog
- HTTP status codes and network errors – Google Search Central
- 404 Not Found – MDN Web Docs
- At Least 66.5% of Links to Sites in the Last 9 Years Are Dead – Ahrefs (2022)
- 404 vs 410: The Technical SEO Experiment – Reboot Online
- Google Offers Advice on 404 and 410 Status Codes – Search Engine Journal
Jul.2026By Studio JT