Manual Action
A manual action is a penalty issued when a Google reviewer, a human, judges that pages on a site do not comply with the spam policies. GSC Help Center It differs from what the ranking algorithms handle automatically in that human judgment is involved.
Google explains that it catches policy violations with automated systems, but where needed, human review leads to a manual action. Google (official) In other words, the same violation can follow two separate paths: an automatic ranking drop, or a manual action by a person. In the industry, this is commonly called a Google penalty. Ahrefs
Notices arrive in two places
When a manual action is applied, a notice arrives in two places in Google Search Console: the Manual Actions report and the message center. GSC Help Center Conversely, on a site with no action, the report shows a green check mark and a message. That screen is your confirmation that there’s no problem. GSC Help Center
So if your site isn’t registered in Search Console, it’s easy to miss that you’ve been hit. That’s part of why it’s recommended to register a new site first thing when you launch it.
There are two broad groups of types
If you open the official documentation and count, there are 15 types on the web search side and 16 on the News and Discover policy side. Google doesn’t state a total, and the list grows or shrinks whenever the policies change, so it’s better to look at what groups exist than at the numbers. GSC Help Center Here are the ones you’ll see most often on the web search side.
- Major spam problems – Mass-producing pages, using cloaking to show Google and people different content, or repeatedly and seriously violating the policies. It’s one of the few types where the official description names the site, not specific pages, as the subject.
- Unnatural links to your site – Artificial, deceptive patterns are detected in the backlinks pointing to your site.
- Unnatural links from your site – The reverse: the links your site sends out are manipulative. Selling links for money is the classic example.
- Thin content with little or no added value – Low-quality or shallow pages are detected on the site.
- Cloaking and sneaky redirects – The page shown to Google differs from the page shown to users, or users are sent to a different page from the one Google saw.
- Hidden text and keyword stuffing – Planting invisible text or forcing in keywords.
- User-generated spam – Spam posted by visitors. It mostly shows up in forums, guestbooks and member profiles.
- Site reputation abuse – A tactic that piggybacks third-party content on the ranking signals a site has already built up; also called parasite SEO.
- Structured data issues – Marking up (adding code that search engines read) content that users can’t see, or marking up irrelevant or misleading content.
- Back button hijacking – Preventing people from leaving a page even when they press the back button.
The rest are cloaked images, sneaky mobile redirects, AMP content mismatch, sites abused with third-party spam, and spammy free hosts. GSC Help Center These apply, respectively, when images shown in search results differ from those on the actual site, when only mobile users are redirected somewhere crawlers can’t see, and when a significant share of sites on a free web hosting service are spam.
All of the type names tie back to definitions in the spam policies document. Cloaking is defined as showing different content with the intent to manipulate rankings and mislead users, link spam as creating links primarily to manipulate rankings, and scaled content abuse as mass-producing pages to manipulate rankings rather than to help users. Google (official) Expired domain abuse, buying expired domains and putting low-value content on them, is in the same document. Google (official)
Hacked content sits elsewhere. The spam policies define it as content placed on a site without permission through security vulnerabilities. Google (official) However, hacked content isn’t in the list of manual action types; in Search Console, a separate Security Issues report handles it. GSC Help Center
If you’re hit, you drop out of search results
If there’s a manual action, the affected pages or site are ranked lower or removed from search results entirely. Nothing is shown on the user-facing side. GSC Help Center The spam policies document says the same thing: sites that violate the policies may rank lower or not appear in results at all. Google (official)
The scope depends on the type. Some actions target only a specific section of the site, such as site reputation abuse, while in other cases the report shows the entire site as affected. GSC Help Center If the whole site is affected, even searches for your brand name can be impacted.
The order for lifting it: fix, explain, wait
Fix every affected page
Google says that fixing only some of the pages won’t get you even a partial recovery. GSC Help Center First figure out the scope of the action, then fix every page within it.
For link issues there’s a set order. First make a genuine effort to actually remove the problem links, and only use the disavow links tool (which asks Google to ignore those links) for the ones you ultimately couldn’t remove. GSC Help Center Starting with the disavow tool isn’t the official order.
A reconsideration request includes three things
Google lists three qualities of a good request: it explains the exact quality issue on the site, describes the steps taken to fix it, and documents the outcome. GSC Help Center What the reviewer checks isn’t an apology but what you changed and how.
Before submitting a request, also make sure Google can access the affected pages. If they require login, sit behind a paywall (a wall that lets only paying subscribers see content), are blocked by robots.txt, or have a noindex directive applied, the reviewer can’t check them. GSC Help Center
Don’t resubmit before you get a result
Review usually takes several days to a few weeks, and link-related requests can take longer than usual. GSC Help Center That wording is all Google says about timing, so any claim that it’ll be lifted within a few days goes beyond the official explanation. Google also says not to resubmit the same request before you get a result. GSC Help Center
Not every traffic drop is a manual action
Google’s list of causes for search traffic drops includes a spam issues item, and there it tells you to check the Manual Actions report in Search Console. Google (official) If that’s empty, the cause lies elsewhere. Google says that if rankings dropped because of an algorithm update, there may be nothing fundamentally wrong with the content itself. Google (official)
| Google’s official position | Core updates are broad changes and don’t target specific sites or individual pages. A page that dropped isn’t necessarily a bad page. Google compares it to a list of your 20 favorite restaurants: when you rewrite the list a few years later, new restaurants come in and some get pushed down, but that doesn’t mean those restaurants got worse. Google (official) |
|---|---|
| Industry reporting | In 2024, the site reputation abuse policy was enforced through manual actions, not the algorithm, and the affiliate marketing sections of major news publishers were targeted. Industry observers reported that as of late 2024, only about ten or so indexed URLs appeared to remain for CNN Underscored. Search Engine Journal However, observers also noted that those actions targeted easy-to-identify cases first, such as coupon sections attached to major media sites, and that it wasn’t confirmed whether the broad drop in affiliate content in the second half of 2024 was due to manual actions or algorithmic changes. At the time, Google said it was not testing a site reputation abuse algorithm. GSQI analysis |
The key point of this case is that the same policy can be enforced in two ways. A manual action leaves a trace in the report and can be reversed with a reconsideration request, but an algorithmic change leaves nothing in the report and isn’t eligible for reconsideration, because there’s no violation to report.
If the report is empty but traffic has dropped, the next step is other data. Check site-wide indexing status in the Page Indexing report, and the status of individual URLs with the URL Inspection tool. Also look at seasonal swings and declining demand for the queries themselves. Google (official)
References
- How to use the Manual Actions report and fix each type – Google Search Console Help Center
- Full text of Google’s web search spam policies – Google Search Central
- How to diagnose search traffic drops step by step – Google Search Central
- What core updates are and how to respond to drops – Google Search Central
- How the site reputation abuse crackdown affected major news publishers – Search Engine Journal
- Telling manual actions apart from algorithmic changes for affiliate content – GSQI
- Summary of what manual actions are and how they’re lifted – Ahrefs SEO Glossary
Aug.2026By Studio JT